ing me how his latest offering is. I myself thought Mani is at crossroads of his career even as I was awaiting GURU. That is because the times when he had his greatest hits were drastically different than today’s times. His releases were talked about due to his high dramatic themes and excellent technical values. Mani’s themes and characters are rooted in reality. I am talking about the days of Roja, Bombay, Iruvar, Dilse. They surely made news because it was like selling hot political themes, partly or fully controversial. At the box office, that was his USP. His superb taking of course is unmatched even today. But with so much of television and controversies around I was not sure he still retained his USP. The technical values his movies were high on are no more his lone Preserve. Even flops in Tamil have superb technical values these days, thanks to pioneers like Mani. So what is Mani's movies' USP now?I think Mani’s career turning point was with Iruvar and Dilse. By this time, Mani had significant success at BO and he must be thinking about new challenges in terms of wider audience and universal content. Till then he skillfully made a career out of explosive (Nayagan, Roja, Bombay) and mythological (Mahabharata-like Dalapati, Savitri-like Roja, Karna-like Agni Nakshatram). He tapped the emotions of the audience successfully. But an MBA guy like him who reads heavily, following world cinema closely surely must be ambitious and he was. His movies show his thirst for excellence and his attempt like Thiruda Thiruda after a phenomenal success with Roja only shows his ambition to break out his comfort zone and get critical and commercial success. After all, despite commercial success, his movies doesn't really have the deep insights. Roja and Bombay were like news in a daily but were not really social or political commentaries. I mean a Bombay pales in front of something like Aparna Sen’s Mr and Mrs Iyer. Mani himself declared he is a pucca commercial filmmaker. And of course he want to be one, ..like Spielberg, who can make a Jurassic Park as well as Schindler’s List. Universal themes they were and Mani had his plans and dreams. But Alas, Fate has different plans. With an ambitious Iruvar (which I think is his boldest attempt till date) failing at BO, Mani, I think, went on the backfoot. Dilse too wasn’t up to his writing standards and its failure too drove him back to Tamil right into his safe haven of ‘love stories’/ inter-personal relations in form of Alaipayuthey. Calling this safe may look far-fetched but I have a gut feeling that he can easily make great love stories although he didn’t do many apart from Mouna Ragam and Geetanjali. For such a great artist, its natural to have a keen eye on relations.
Alaipayuthey’s success financially must have consoled him as Tamil yet again proved safe zone. So he starts his second innings and makes a Kannathil Muthamittal to cross over into critical acclaim. It was a real serious effort. We even heard he was making it without songs. But Mani’s movies seem to be so dependent on AR Rahman. (Even a flop like Dilse is unthinkable without ARR.) So Kannathil..gets songs and we get a not-so-great script. It was a good attempt but a lot more is desired to take him to world stage with strong BO collections. Mani seemed to be improvising and he seems to have made up his mind to get into the depths of issues rather than making superficial stuff. Kannathil Muthamittal proved that. So did Aayitha Ezhuthu. Yet again he took an off-beat theme and which is very close to Indian psyche. There sure were comparisons with Spanish film Amores Perros in terms of structure. And that point must be noted. Ofcourse, Mani has his eyes on critical acclaim in world cinema. However, once again, the script wasn’t up to the mark in Aayitha Ezhuthu. In fact the Hindi version is his worst film ever, in other words, its his only ‘bad film’. Everything went wrong in that movie. So, Mani’s second innings that started with Kannathil.. where content takes the centrestage in his movies and all else, including music, takes backstage. Kannathil ..showed blood relations in an environment of ethnic and political strife. Aayitha Ezhuthu showed different strata of a vast society. Both were moderate successes and so Mani now again thinks about Hindi to break onto the big stage. To try again what he missed with Dilse. Hopefully, he must be more prepared now in content as well as language! He was aiming at younger audience with Yuva and here again he chooses a subject (Guru) that aims at the same niche audience. Understandable how bad a break he needs to stick to the path he chose and still get the eluding commercial success. In this scenario comes Guru which will dictate his path henceforth. Guru should be showing how Mani evolved and how he can connect to the new generation.
GURU
There is something about backdrop and milieu in movie content. I mean what can be more appealing than a story of a business czar in the changing times of license-permit raj a
nd his humble beginnings in a dusty Gujarat village. When I first heard about Guru, I thought Mani is making a movie that reflected India’s changing times of 80s and 90s. The Gujarati angle adds the flavor to it just as the Italian backdrop adds to Godfather. When I first heard about RGV Sarcar, I imagined it would be setup in the Hindi heartland with all the raw look. Alas, RGV was not that imaginative! Vishal Bhardwaj tapped the same so skillfully in Omkara. Coming back to Guru, despite the excitement of the challenging content, It was clear all along that with such content, Guru’s fate would firmly and completely depend on the younger audience. It never crossed my mind that he would make something like Citizen Kane as he never inclined to make such things before. And true to my guess he didn’t. But even my guess wasn’t right. Guru is no Citizen Kane but it didn’t even reflect the changing times of 80s. I am not one of those who keep proposing that Mani made a career out of sensationalism in his movies. Even when it was clear, Guru has its inspiration in Ambani, I felt it is incidental. When he need to show the businesses of 80s, its natural for him to show the tactics of the most successful guy of that time. I thought the media was rather being sensationalistic! After seeing Guru, I really wondered Mani is up to. The film almost ended up a biopic, and a bad one at that. Complete with the DuPont machinery in Shakti Industries! It is neither the story of an individual’s struggle nor is it about India’s most important economic era that gave birth to free enterprise. Abhishek just does a mini Kamal Hassan and in these days of Bollywood movies, that is stupendous acting! I am not saying Abhishek didn’t perform. He did but its definitely not over-the-top performance, what with such a nice author-backed protected role which is not exposed too much. And the fact that the movie is talked about only for Abhishek’s performance shows the failure of the focus in content. Guru should have stressed more on the times it was set in. It took for granted the audience knows all about license raj and how it was obstructing free enterprise. The result: Many in audience wondered what the film is all about. After all, if at all they saw economic ideologies in movies, it was only the glorification of socialism in good old days. For a brief minute in the climax, I wished Gurubhai will (at least) break into a lengthy monologue ala Howard Roark in Fountainhead. Its well known Mani is influenced by Ayn Rand. But even that was not to be! So Guru ends up a focus-less superficial movie glossed over with a star couple and some great music and background score and Mani seems to be back on the Bombay path. The gumption he showed in content of two of his earlier movies is missing. Pucca commercial (that’s what he called himself in an interview). What a movie it would have been, if he went the extra mile. Pity, he missed out tapping the great theme. So, we have to wait for Mani to get that great theme and make his magnum opus, our Crouching Tiger, Hidden dragon. The problem is, at 51 he is not getting any younger. The irony is, this is still the best Bollywood can offer. Even more ironic is I came out of theatre (first day, first show) smiling! After all, Mani is back on the big stage with this commercial success and now with the new-found security, he may again resume his second innings with his next film. Eternal optimist, I am.
